A (In)adequada recepção da ponderação Alexyana pelo direito brasileiro

Abstract

The importance about decide in a Law Democratic State are associated with the perfect notion about difference between choosing and deciding, according to Lenio Streck. Torendertheir decisions the judge can’t actpartially, discretion. Because judgingisnotan actof choice, to deciderequires a real constitutional commitment. However, at present, there is in Brasil the introductionof international theory that whose elementsand techniques highlights the judicial discretion.Including the “teoria da Argumentação Jurídica” os Robert Alexy, and the technique of weighting, when happen the collision between fundamental rights.It’s necessary to analyze the origin of this theory in their legal and philosophical environment, namely, the jurisprudence of values in Germany, and and their evidence to conclude it was inadequate to Brazilian law.It is possible to observe the incorporation of this theoryin Brazilian Law for his constant presencein several national legal works, especially inconstitutional lawbooks, and the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court. Because of the high burden of discretion linked to this theorythis attitudemust be fought. Like a way ofcopingagainstjudicial discretion it is proposed the “theory ofjudicial decision” of Lenio Luiz Streck.